Skip to main content

Scottish Terrier vs West Highland White Terrier

Look-alike breeds
By Dog Breed Detector · Updated Nov 18, 2026

The Scottish Terrier and the West Highland White Terrier are small, short-legged terriers from Scotland that stand about 10 in at the shoulder. Both have small prick ears, an upright tail that is never docked, a hard double coat and dark eyes set in under the brow. The AKC history describes the terriers of Scotland as branches of one family tree.

Colour is the fastest tell. A Westie is white, as its name says. A Scottie is black, wheaten or brindle, and its standard allows white only to a slight extent on the chest and chin. A black or brindle dog is therefore not a Westie, and a clear colour photo settles most cases.

The pale wheaten Scottie is the exception, and there the head decides it. A Scottie's head is long for its size, with a muzzle about as long as the skull and a beard. A Westie's head looks roundish from the front, with a blunt muzzle slightly shorter than the skull and hair shaped into a round frame for the face.

Quick facts

FactScottish TerrierWest Highland White Terrier
GroupTerrierTerrier
Sizesmallsmall
Height10 in10-11 in
Weight18-22 lbs15-20 lbs
Lifespan12 years13-15 years
TemperamentIndependent, Loyal, Confident, AlertConfident, Friendly, Independent, Spirited

How to tell them apart

Read the rows top to bottom. The first two or three traits usually settle it; the rest confirm.

TraitScottish TerrierWest Highland White Terrier
ColourBlack, wheaten or brindle of any colour. Black and brindle dogs often have a sprinkling of white or silver hairs. White is allowed only slightly, on the chest and chin.White. The standard prefers a hard, straight coat with some wheaten tipping to a soft white coat.
Head and muzzleLong in proportion to the dog. Skull and muzzle form two parallel planes with a slight stop, and the muzzle is about equal in length to the skull with only a slight taper.Roundish seen from the front. The skull is broad and slightly longer than the muzzle, with a defined stop, and the muzzle is blunt.
SizeAbout 10 in and 18 to 22 lbs. The AKC standard gives 19 to 22 lbs for males and 18 to 21 lbs for females.10 to 11 in and 15 to 20 lbs. The AKC standard gives 11 in for males and 10 in for females, and no weight.
BodyThick-set and cobby, hung between short, heavy legs, with a very deep chest. The standard gives a back length of about 11 in, slightly more than the height.Compact and short-coupled. The body from withers to tail is slightly shorter than the height at the withers, and the forelegs are long enough to keep the dog from being too close to the ground.
TailAbout 7 in long, thick at the base and tapering to a point, carried erect, either vertical or with a slight forward curve.Relatively short and shaped like a carrot, carried upright. When erect it does not reach above the top of the skull.
Coat and trimHard, wiry outer coat over a soft, dense undercoat, trimmed to give the Scottie outline, with longer furnishings on the beard, legs and lower body.Straight, hard outer coat of about 1.5 to 2 in on the body over a short, soft undercoat, with the head hair plucked and shaped into a round frame.
AKC group and originTerrier Group, recognised in 1885. Developed to hunt rats, foxes and badgers in the Scottish Highlands.Terrier Group, recognised in 1908. Bred in the Scottish Highlands to hunt badger and vermin, and associated with the Malcolm family's Poltalloch estate.

What the photo detector sees

In a clear colour photo, coat colour separates this pair, and in the saved benchmark runs for this project none of the tested AI models gave the other breed as its first answer for either breed's reference photos. The Scottish Terrier was the second suggestion in six of the fourteen saved answers for Westie photos, and the Westie was the second suggestion in one of the sixteen saved answers for Scottie photos.

Colour stops helping in black-and-white pictures, in strong light that bleaches a wheaten Scottie, and with pet dogs clipped short all over, which loses the trimmed outline each standard describes. Use the length of the head and muzzle and the length of the tail in those cases. A small, shaggy terrier of another colour may be neither breed: the AKC history counts the Cairn, Skye and Dandie Dinmont terriers in the same Scottish family.

Living with them

Both are confident, independent terriers with a strong instinct to chase. The Scottish Terrier standard describes a dog that is loving and gentle with people but can be aggressive with other dogs, and the AKC describes Scotties as aloof toward strangers. The West Highland White Terrier standard lists the breed as alert, courageous, self-reliant and friendly. The AKC says a Westie will run after anything that moves and does best on a lead or in a fenced area, and that a Scottie needs a good walk plus bursts of play. It describes an independent streak in both that can make training a challenge, and suggests short sessions of no more than 15 minutes for a Scottie.

Both coats need regular work. The AKC says both are traditionally hand-stripped and that pet coats are often clipped instead, a Scottie every six to eight weeks and a Westie with a groomer every four to six weeks. It advises weekly brushing for a Scottie and daily brushing for a Westie, and warns that bathing a Westie too often can do more harm than good. The profiles list a lifespan of 12 years for the Scottish Terrier and 13 to 15 years for the West Highland White Terrier.

Not sure which one you have?

Upload a clear photo and the detector returns a ranked shortlist, so you can check the top matches against the tells above instead of guessing from one label.

Upload a photo and get a ranked shortlist

FAQ

What is the difference between a Scottish Terrier and a West Highland White Terrier?

Colour and head shape. A Westie is always white, with a roundish head and a blunt muzzle. A Scottish Terrier is black, wheaten or brindle, with a long head, a beard and a heavier, lower-slung body of 18 to 22 lbs against 15 to 20 lbs for the Westie.

Are Scotties and Westies related?

The AKC history says it is thought that the terriers of Scotland, including the Westie, Cairn, Skye, Scottish and Dandie Dinmont terriers, are all branches of the same family tree. It describes the Scottish Terrier as thought to be the oldest of the Highland terriers. The AKC registers them as separate breeds.

Which is bigger, a Scottie or a Westie?

They are about the same height, and the Scottie is heavier. The Scottish Terrier stands about 10 in and weighs 18 to 22 lbs. The West Highland White Terrier stands 10 to 11 in and weighs 15 to 20 lbs.

Can a Scottish Terrier be white?

Not under the AKC standard, which lists black, wheaten and brindle and allows white only slightly on the chest and chin. A wheaten Scottie can be very pale, which is where the confusion with a Westie comes from. Its long head and muzzle still mark it as a Scottie.

How do their grooming needs differ?

Both have hard coats that are hand-stripped or clipped. The AKC suggests weekly brushing for a Scottish Terrier and clipping every six to eight weeks if the coat is not stripped. For a Westie it advises daily brushing and a visit to a groomer every four to six weeks.

Full profiles

More look-alikes

Other comparisons that include one of these breeds or come from the same look-alike group:

Browse every pair in the breed comparison index.